I fucking hate Sharty for its pedohysteria, but being attracted to 16 years olds indeed makes you a pedophile.
I would rather criticize them for their actually pedohysteric rants. Not just typical "think about muh drawings" shit that they justify by referring to Australia's laws which is a country whose government gets butthurt over the slightest drop of blood in video games. I mean actually idiotic shit like I remember how they got butthurt over the episode of South Park where kids were jerking off to a dog and accused Trey Parker and Matt Stone of pedophilia. Only because they depicted a minors performing a sexual action on an animal. Despite the fact that authors' intentions were obviously not to sexualize minors.